The Good Place S1E9 - "...Someone Like Me as a Member"
Spoiler Warning: This reflection contains full spoilers for The Good Place, including retrospective insights and thematic allusions. It assumes familiarity with the entire series and is written from the perspective of a rewatch.
From the moment she steps off the train, “Real Eleanor” (or rather, Demon Eleanor) exerts a quiet, suffocating pressure on the group—particularly on Eleanor Shellstrop. She’s everything Eleanor thinks she’s not: kind, composed, noble. Her life story is harrowing and heroic, culminating in the exact kind of self-sacrifice the afterlife supposedly rewards. Of course, it’s all a performance. But in the context of Michael’s grand design—where every element exists to destabilize the core four—this isn’t about reward. It’s about psychological erosion. Real Eleanor isn’t here to replace our Eleanor. She’s here to haunt her.
What makes this episode unnerving isn’t just the gaslighting—it’s the quiet orchestration behind it. Michael is spinning the chessboard, reasserting control after Eleanor’s public confession and the unexpected loyalty of Chidi. Trevor brings chaos. The dinner is a disaster. Janet and Jason start inching toward something strange and tender. It’s all motion, all pressure—less about philosophy this time and more about emotional discomfort. The game has changed, and the show knows it. Everyone is still playing along, but the walls are beginning to hum.
And at the center of it all is Eleanor, spiraling in her own slow realization. She’s jealous, yes, but more than that—she’s unfamiliar with being part of a group. Her flashbacks show a life spent on the outside, keeping others at arm’s length. Being honest, being vulnerable, being one of many—it’s not a moral failing, it’s a muscle she’s never used. So when she finally says, “I want to be part of the group,” it lands softly, but deeply. She’s not being manipulated in that moment. She’s not trying to scheme her way in. She just wants to belong.
And that—ironically, painfully—is what makes her dangerous to Michael’s design. Not her lies. Her longing.
Comments ()